Using lazy and concurrentdictionary to ensure a thread. That is a valid concern but using remove is not the right way to go. Is this the correct usage of concurrentdictionary t have any concurrency issues, i decided to make a simple class that uses a concurrencydictionary. Why is immutabledictionary implementing idictionary. English dictionary is a collection of words and their definitions, often listed alphabetically in one or more specific languages.
Concurrentdictionary the fully threadsafe dictionary. I soon discovered that theres a fair bit of plumbing required to. Itemtkey property to add new elements by setting the value of a key that does not exist in the dictionary. For context related problems, you can use callcontext. I think the tryadd is not the best choice for a new method on this collection type, because i believe it has limited applicability compared to an alternative tvalue dictionary. Logicalgetdata, which is merely an idictionary which flows between contexts, and has a copyonwrite shallow copy semantics. This morning, i posted a base class to assist with implementing idictionary. Concurrentdictionary tkey, tvalue ienumerable tkey, tvalue initializes a new instance of the concurrentdictionary tkey, tvalue class that contains elements copied from the specified ienumerable, has the default concurrency level, has the default initial capacity, and uses the default comparer for the key type.
The following code example creates an empty dictionary tkey, tvalue of strings with string keys and uses the add method to add some elements. While this is a fantastic replacement for dictionary, it has a potential flaw when used with values where construction of the value class is expensive. This problem only seems to occur when the key is a collection type, i have tried substituting the byte for a list. Public function trygetvalue key as tkey, byref value as tvalue as boolean. As i mentioned this was just the first chunk of work required as part of my goal of building a generic dictionary which uses weak references for its keys and values. The dictionary program will failyou cannot add an existing element. Therefore this idea seems safe, and i would definitely make use of it. This type implements icollection, ienumerable, system. Presenting weakdictionarytkey, tvalue nick guerreras blog. Concurrentdictionary can be used with multiple threads concurrently.
However, if the specified key already exists in the dictionary, setting the system. As noted in the msdn documentation, concurrentdictionary represents a threadsafe collection of key value pairs that can be accessed by multiple threads concurrently. I think the point he was trying to make is that if you try to iterate over a collection using the ienumerable t interface, that you will see higher gc cost because the ienumerator t that it returns will be boxed the issue is not specific to dictionary and idictionary you would hypothetically run into the same issue trying to enumerate a hashset t through its. Note that the request methods func parameter called createproxybuilder. Thus, avl trees can be used to implement dictionaries that can add new elements, remove elements, and find keys in olog n time in the worst case, not counting the cost of comparing keys. Each and every key must be unique in the dictionary. The concurrentdictionary is the threadsafe counterpart to the generic dictionary collection. The dictionary class the generic term for a data structure providing storage and retrieval via keys, but not necessarily the ability to process the data in any particular order, is dictionary.
The observabledictionary tkey, tvalue type exposes the following members. Oct 23, 2015 using lazy and concurrentdictionary to ensure a threadsafe, runonce, lazyloaded collection october 23, 2015 by mike larah since. Uses the specified functions to add a key value pair to the concurrentdictionary tkey, tvalue if the key does not already exist, or to update a key value pair in the concurrentdictionary tkey, tvalue if the key already exists. If there is already a value associated with the given key, it throws an argumentexception. Addtkey,tvalue method does not modify existing elements. The getoradd function the concurrentdictionary is a dictionary that allows you to add, fetch and remove items in a threadsafe way. Jun 05, 2015 dictionary isn t sealed, but the core methods aren t virtual unlike, for instance, collection t. Icollection value public readonly property values as icollectionof tvalue. We could alter our safedictionary to use a concurrentdictionary internally, and remove all of our internal locks.
This is done to prevent unknown code from blocking all threads. I have dictionary value which keeps online clients in the server, and i make it thread safe by locking object when i have access to it. Gets a value that indicates whether the concurrentdictionary tkey,tvalue is empty. Initializes a new instance of the dictionary class that is empty, has the specified initial capacity, and uses the default equality comparer for the key type. Net 4, and provides a threadsafe, lock free collection of key value pairs. While its reasonably easy to use weakreference as the tvalue in dictionary t exist in the collection and the parallel. The namedmap tkey, tvalue semantics follow the signature of the concurrentdictionary class in microsofts system. A key cannot be null, but a value can be, if the value type tvalue is a reference type. Jan 08, 2010 concurrentdictionary is a new type in the. Concurrent collections address the race condition and thread safety inside their implementation e. Since theres no such collection available in the bcl, i set out to build it. Tvalue when this method returns, contains the object removed from the concurrentdictionary tkey, tvalue, or the default value of the tvalue type if key does not exist. Concurrent namespace and it uses scaleout stateserver to store keys and values.
When this method returns, contains the object from the concurrentdictionary tkey,tvalue that has the specified key, or the default value of the type if the operation failed. While its reasonably easy to use weakreference as the tvalue in dictionary feb 15, 20 the concurrentdictionary will generate a myclass object if it doesn t exist in the collection and the parallel. Observabledictionary tkey, tvalue class an implementation of idictionary which fires inotifycollectionchanged and inotifypropertychanged when required. Add in the immutabledictionary class throws a notsupportedexception see here so, what was the point in doing this. I was recently asked by a developer about getting some additional information out of concurrentdictionary s getoradd method. Concurrentstack t and concurrentdictionary aug 06, 2010 also, although all methods of concurrentdictionary are threadsafe, not all methods are atomic, specifically getoradd and addorupdate. First the code that uses it so you can get a feel for how easy it is to use. Your aim seems to be to improve code clarity by removing the need to use an out parameter. Getoraddtkey, tvalue unlike tryadd which returns a bool, the getoradd method would return the actual instance associated with a specified key in the dictionary. In fact, the current implementation of idictionary. However, this does require some changes to how the buckets are implemented. Count already equals the capacity, the capacity of the dictionary is increased.
To make a concurrentdictionary only call a delegate once when using getoradd, store your values as lazy t, and use by calling getoraddkey, valuefactory. Namedmap tkey, tvalue represents a threadsafe collection of key value pairs that can be accessed by multiple threads concurrently. We equally welcome both specific questions as well as openended discussions. Calling add with the same key and multiple values will store each value under the same key in the dictionary. The implicit linked list within a single backing array used by the nonconcurrent dictionary adds a dependency between separate buckets, as every bucket uses the same backing array. This class can store more than one value for every key. The example demonstrates that the add method throws an argumentexception when. The map contents are coherent across the inmemory data. This ensures that each bucket is entirely separate from all. Initializes a new instance of the dictionary tkey, tvalue class that is empty, has the specified initial capacity, and uses the default equality comparer for the key type. Building a custom getoradd method for concurrentdictionary. Instead, concurrentdictionary uses a strict linked list on each bucket. Readwise, they both implement ireadonlydictionary, which is fine.
Generic namespace its a generic collection which is generally used to store key value pairs data. Using collections as key in dictionary value, it tries to find the key which matches the specified reference value, rather than matching the contents at the references address. Assembly mscorlib library bcl summary represents a readonly collection of keys in a dictionary. Obviously, both are designed for quick o1 lookups of data based on a key. If we don t mind exposing extra methods we can remove all of the implementation from safedictionary and just derive it from concurrentdictionary. Jun 04, 2006 this morning, i posted a base class to assist with implementing idictionary.
Foreach may request for the same key simultaneously. Concurrentstack t and concurrentdictionary are threadsafe, not all methods are atomic, specifically getoradd and addorupdate. Because you can leverage an existing data structures logic and merely forbid the disallowed operations, instead of writing a complete data structure from scratch. Without concurrentdictionary class, if we have to use dictionary. Concurrentdictionary is one of five collection classes introduced in. The user delegate that is passed to these methods is invoked outside of the dictionarys internal lock. This allows the dictionary to be used as a data source for silverlight and wpf user controls implementing databinding. Using lazy and concurrentdictionary to ensure a threadsafe. I don t have a need of the class in the past and want to make sure it is being used correctly as the documentation seems to lack a bit for this class, mostly when it comes to updating values and the like. If by chance the entry does not exist, and two threads ask for the same key, concurrentdictionary executes both constructors simultaneously and registers one of them. As a reminder, getoradd either returns the value for a key currently in the dictionary, or if that key doesn t have a value, it adds a value for the key as dictated by either a tvalue provided by the caller or by executing a func.
It makes adding, removing and updating values in a lookup table on multiple threads easier. Making concurrentdictionary getoradd thread safe using lazy. Concurrentdictionarys support for adding and updating. Removes the given key and its associated value from the dictionary, and returns whether the key was found. The collection also has addorupdate and getoradd methods that accept delegate value factories, so that you can lazily load your values only when you need to initialize them. Consider adding getoradd and addorupdate overloads to concurrentdictionary, tvalue that take a targ factoryargument parameter, to avoid closure allocations this would be consistent with what already ships as part of the immutable collections, where there is an extension method for immutabledictionary that takes such an argument see. It looks like a weird design choice, because a dictionary and an immutabledictionary are quite different writewise. Jan 16, 2011 the concurrentdictionary class was added in. Consider adding getoradd and addorupdate overloads to concurrentdictionary, tvalue that take a targ factoryargument parameter, to avoid closure allocations this would be consistent with what already ships as part of the immutable collections, where there is an extension method for immutabledictionary that takes such an argument see immutableinterlocked. Reach out to all the awesome people in our software development community by starting your own topic.
284 180 565 1237 868 1212 340 262 1249 727 1206 452 624 1570 252 90 904 564 1116 479 83 1640 1415 552 1171 1247 738 545 1531 35 667 276 1055 5 285 252 1407 236 360 1274 271 615 52 997 1209 149 1419